Is Toggle Auto Insurance Legit? Let’s Find Out!

Toggle Auto Insurance might be new to the insurance scene, but it’s a legit auto insurance provider and a solid option for certain customers.

However, this doesn’t guarantee that you’ll receive the best coverage at the most competitive price.

It’s always important to compare insurance providers before committing to one.

Please continue reading to find out the coverage options offered by Toggle Auto Insurance.

An image of Toggle Auto Insurance
Source: valuepenguin

Is Toggle Auto Insurance Legit?

Toggle Auto Insurance is a real and officially recognized insurance provider.

It’s part of the Farmers Insurance Group, a company with more than 90 years in the insurance business.

Established in 2018, Toggle represents Farmers Insurance Group’s fresh take on renters insurance.

Additionally, it caters to those seeking swift and straightforward online policy personalization, offering distinctive extras like side hustle coverage and options tailored for pet parents.

Standard plans from Toggle typically include protection against flood and earthquake damages, which are often premium services with other insurers.

Nonetheless, Toggle’s renters insurance is not yet accessible in every state.

What Sets Toggle Auto Insurance Apart

Toggle distinguishes itself in the following ways:

Coverage: Toggle’s basic policies include protections that are typically costly add-ons with other insurers, or not offered at all. This encompasses safeguards against floods, earthquakes, personal injury liability, bedbug treatment, and sewer backup.

Partner Benefits: While Toggle doesn’t provide discounts on its rental insurance, customers can benefit from savings on a variety of products and services through its partnership deals.

Areas Where Toggle Auto Insurance Lacks

However, Toggle has areas where it does not perform as well:

Customer Complaints: Compared to its peers, Toggle receives a significantly larger number of complaints filed with state regulatory bodies.

Digital Presence: Despite having a user-friendly website, Toggle lacks a dedicated mobile application for policy management.

Coverage Options by Toggle Auto Insurance

Toggle’s auto insurance comes with a suite of standard protections, including:

Liability: This covers injuries and property damage you may cause to others if you’re at fault in an accident.

Collision: This takes care of damages to your vehicle resulting from a collision with another object.

Comprehensive: This provides coverage for your car against non-collision incidents like theft, vandalism, or natural disasters.

Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist: This offers financial protection if an inadequately insured driver hits you.

Beyond these fundamental coverages, Toggle also proposes additional benefits:

Roadside Assistance: This service assists with common roadside troubles like flat tires, battery issues, and vehicle lockouts.

Rental Car Reimbursement: This pays for your rental car expenses while your own car is under repair following an accident.

Gap Insurance: This covers the gap between your car’s actual cash value and the amount you still owe on it, in the event of a total loss.

These offerings bolster the overall value and practicality of Toggle’s policies, positioning it as a desirable option for motorists in search of thorough coverage.

Costs and Discounts

Toggle is known for its attractive pricing strategy.

Using a specialized algorithm, Toggle calculates insurance rates by taking into account personal factors like driving records, the type of vehicle you have, and where you live.

This method often leads to lower insurance costs than those offered by traditional insurers.

Toggle also offers a variety of discounts to reduce your expenses even more, such as:

Multi-car discount: Lower your rates by insuring more than one vehicle with Toggle.

Good driver discount: Get rewarded with lower premiums for having a spotless driving record.

Paperless billing discount: Choose electronic billing and enjoy a reduction in your bill.

Taking advantage of these discounts can lead to significant savings and make Toggle’s pricing even more economical.

Financial Details

Toggle Auto Insurance’s financial solidity is bolstered by its association with the established Farmers Insurance Group.

Despite being newer than some of its seasoned rivals, Toggle benefits from the financial vigor of its parent company, ensuring reliability in meeting its fiscal duties.

A.M. Best Rating: Farmers Insurance Group holds an A- (excellent) rating from A.M. Best, reflecting a robust capacity to honor its financial commitments to policyholders.

Financial Size Category XV: This classification denotes that Farmers Insurance Group possesses assets over $2 billion, reinforcing its financial robustness.

Stable Outlook: A.M. Best has reconfirmed the A- rating and predicts a steady financial outlook for the foreseeable future.

Support and Claims Handling

Toggle offers an accessible online system for managing policies and filing claims.

However, there have been customer reports of difficulties with the claims procedure, noting delays in responses, insufficient interaction from claims representatives, and hurdles in obtaining equitable settlements.

It’s important to note that such issues may not represent the experiences of most Toggle customers, but they are worth considering when evaluating this insurance provider.

Customer Reviews

Toggle Auto Insurance is unquestionably a legit insurance provider, yet customer feedback varies.

The company is often praised for its easy online quoting, competitive pricing, and adaptable coverage that meets diverse needs.

On the other hand, some reviews point to issues in the claims process, with complaints about poor communication, delayed resolutions, and unexpected challenges.

Additionally, there are instances of abrupt and substantial hikes in premiums, which have caused dissatisfaction among customers.

For a well-rounded view, it’s important to review customer experiences on platforms like Trustpilot, Clearsurance, and Reddit forums.

Considering both the positive and negative reviews can provide a deeper insight into Toggle’s advantages and areas for improvement.


In conclusion, Toggle Auto Insurance is a legit and innovative player in the insurance market.

Backed by the reputable Farmers Insurance Group, Toggle offers a modern approach to auto insurance, emphasizing customization and digital convenience.

While it may have higher-than-average rates and some reported challenges in the claims process, its unique features and coverage options provide value for those looking for tailored insurance solutions.

As with any service, it’s essential to weigh the pros and cons and consider personal needs and preferences.

For those valuing flexibility and customization, Toggle is certainly a legitimate and viable option.

Related Articles:

Leave a Comment