Can an Auto Insurance Company Sue me?

Can an Auto Insurance Company Sue me?

If your residence is in any of the no-fault states mentioned, you are protected from being sued by an auto insurance company in the event of an accident.

However, in at-fault insurance states, the other driver’s insurance company may file a lawsuit against you.

Additionally, if you engage in insurance fraud, your own car insurance company has the right to sue you.

Continue reading to gain insights into the circumstances under which an auto insurance company can take legal action against you for fraud.

In this discussion, we address all your inquiries regarding the potential for a car insurance company to pursue legal action against you.

An image illustrating if an Auto Insurance Company can Sue me
Can an Auto Insurance Company Sue me
Source: (edwardsinjurylaw)

Can Your Own Car Insurance Company Sue You?

Typically, your own car insurance company won’t sue you, but they may take legal action if they suspect insurance fraud.

To avoid issues, be honest with your claims.

Even honest claims may face fraud accusations, and in such cases, providing evidence is crucial.

Fraud claims are treated as crimes, not lawsuits, but legal consultation may be necessary.

While it’s rare, the average driver is unlikely to be sued by their own insurance company.

Varieties of Insurance Fraud

Concerned about potential insurance fraud repercussions from your car insurance company?

There are two main categories:

  1. Hard Fraud Intentionally causing an accident, damaging a vehicle, or creating a false claim to seek compensation from your insurance provider.
  2. Soft Fraud Engaging in a genuine accident but inflating the claim to receive extra compensation.

Regardless of the type, getting caught in fraudulent activities can result in severe consequences, including financial penalties and legal actions.

Insurance companies closely monitor suspicious behavior, such as frequent claims, recent financial difficulties, or adding coverage just before a loss.

Why is your insurance carrier suing you?

Insurance companies may file lawsuits against their policyholders when disputes arise over coverage.

Since an insurance policy is a contractual agreement, courts can intervene in contractual disagreements related to coverage issues.

While policyholders may bring a breach of contract or insurance bad faith claims, insurance companies can also initiate legal actions regarding their contractual obligation to provide coverage.

Typically, insurer-initiated lawsuits involve third-party liability claims, such as a business owner being sued for product-related customer damage or a homeowner facing a lawsuit due to a dog bite incident involving a visitor.

In such cases, the insurer may seek a legal declaration of coverage, adding frustration for the policyholder facing legal action from both the injury victim and their own insurance company.

What to do if your insurance company sues you in a declaratory action?

If your insurance company files a lawsuit against you seeking declaratory relief, it is crucial to promptly seek guidance and representation from an experienced insurance claims lawyer.

The insurer will ask the judge to rule that your claim is not covered.

An image illustration of Auto Insurance Company Sueing me
Auto Insurance Company Sueing me
Source: (bruninglegal)

When should you sue your insurance company?

Deciding when to sue your insurance company depends on various factors.

Including the type of coverage, circumstances of loss, your insurance company’s conduct, efforts to resolve the dispute, and more.

Ultimately, your insurance company is legally obligated to investigate and promptly pay the actual value of your claim.


While it is uncommon for an auto insurance company to sue its policyholders, the possibility exists in cases of suspected fraud or contractual disputes.

Maintaining honesty in claims, providing evidence when needed, and seeking legal advice if facing a lawsuit are essential practices to mitigate such situations.

Overall, the average driver is unlikely to face a lawsuit from their auto insurance company under normal circumstances.


Are Auto Accident Insurance Settlements Taxable?

Are Online Auto Insurance Quotes Accurate?

Leave a Comment